Saturday 15 September 2007

Why not Jumbo? and Indian cricket's future

Rahul Dravid has resigned as the Captain of the Indian cricket team.
The search is on for a new captain (and not to forget a new coach)

The media is teeming with possibilities. Well not really. They have come down to 2 candidates - M.S. Dhoni and S.R. Tendulkar. I must confess that I have never been a big fan of Sachin. Of course, like any cricket admirer, I have enjoyed watching him in full flow. But unlike the majority of the Indian population, for whom Sachin is a living god, my support and admiration was always spent on Brian Charles Lara.

But, its not out of the lack of admiration I say this - Sachin should NOT be made captain., but out of common sense. The man has had two shots at it and failed miserably. Those who clamour for him say that the next few tours are going to be tough ones and that it is necessary for someone with experince to lead the team.

Well, there is one man who comes to mind. He is almost as experienced as Sachin. He is undoubtedly India's greatest match winner ever. Anil Kumble! By far one of the most committed player to the national cause. no one can doubt his work ethic and team spirit. No one doubts his aggressiveness on the field either. Make him captain, give him a decent coach and make the vice-captain someone who will lead the ODI and let these guys along with Sachin, Dada, Robin and Venky take the team through the transition phase.

True, Anil has retired from ODIs. So what? I say. Let him be made the test captain, and make some youngster the ODI captain. Guess MS is the first choice that comes to mind, although I dont think he should be made, I honestly cant see who else can be. The problem with Dhoni is that, he is more of a batsman than a keeper. If he was a better keeper, then one would not have been too worried if his batting suffered under captaincy. But Dhoni's batting is very important to our ODI success and I hope I am wrong when I say this, but in the last couple of tours, MS does seem like he has curtailed his stroke play. Barring that one burst he had at Oval during the third test, I cant remember a typical MS innings for quite some time now. Ironically, its his griity ans somber match saving innings at Lords in the first test that comes to mind when one thinks of his last few memorable innings. MS no doubt is a thinking cricketer who does have a great attitude towards the game.

The sad part of all the commotion that Dravid's resignation has caused is that all the important matters have been pushed aside for the time being. Like India's pathetic fielding. Pathetic is an under statement. Ok, one cantexpect a fielding coach to create miracles, but its not over optimism, if you think that a fielding coach should ensure atleast the basics are not found wanting. Catching a straight forward catch and stopping a ball that is coming straight at you should not be so hard now. Good thing for India is that the malaise of poor fielding seems to have spread to all the international teams for some reason. Even the Aussies had a poor time on the field against Zimbabwe.

I would like to conclude this post by stressing on the importance of Yuvraj Singh for the future. Especially in ODIs. He is definitely the player to watch. In future ODIs, when one takes a look at the ODIs that India triumph in, I will stick my neck out and say that in a majority of the wins Yuvraj would have had a prominent role to play. He is not a leader of men, just let him be!!!

5 comments:

Vish said...

Yuvraj would be a better captain than M.S .. in that case a senior person must take up vice-captaincy... sachin wud fit in that position very easily.. dada can also be considered, despite his bad patch...

hmmm cricket is growing,with IPL being formed!..revenues galore!

Vish said...

yuvraj wud make a good aggressive captain but a not a thinking one! if bouyed by a senior person as a vice captain, yuvraj will look good

M.S is a better player when he doesnt shoulder any responsibility

Vinay Sekhar said...

Well.. I personally dont think Yuvraj should be made captain cos I dont like his attitude. As in he seems to be aloof and more around his set of friends like Bhajji and Zak etc. I maybe wrong, and giving Yuvraj captaincy may make him more responsible.. but Yuvi is not a certainty in tests... MS made captain for ODI and vice captain for tests could be a nice venture, provided he performs as a player.

The way Oz did with Ponting would be ideal. But what works for Oz need not work for us (Greg Chappell will vouch that)

Archs said...

hey you back to blogging! didnt chk your blogspot acct.. thot u were still yonder abound in yercaud.. :-)dhoni has done a good job thus far in t20...as a captain...he shud be doing well in ODI as well... your thot on kumble as a captain is interesting...maybe the man deserves a chance...committed cricketer...we dont know if he cud make a good leader but well there is only one way to find out...give him a chance!

Vinay Sekhar said...

hey archs, ya me had to shift to blogspot cos blogsource kinda shutdown i think ;-) dhoni has been impressive but i still prefer to be apprehensive then base judgement on T20. On the whole, i prefer a new captain rather than go back to Sachin, Dada or Dravid.